5 Signs your website needs a refresh
5 indicators that you need to redesign your website
Why your website matters
Your website is more than a digital brochure. It is often the first real meeting between you and a future customer. If that meeting feels slow, clumsy, or out-of-date, you may never get a second chance.
I review sites for clients every week, and one thing keeps popping up: most site owners do not check performance until sales dip. That is too late. I tell every client to schedule a quick review at least once a quarter and back that review with hard numbers from a tool like Google
Analytics or Duda's built-in analytics. Data removes the guesswork and lets you act before leads vanish.
People Form an opinion about your website (and you) in less than a second
Below are five clear signs it is time for a facelift or a complete rebuild. As you read, keep two added truths in mind:
- No traffic = no sales. A great site still needs a plan to attract visitors. Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) and Pay-Per-Click (PPC) ads are proven ways to drive that traffic.
- Upkeep should not hurt. Our managed website service, for example, includes unlimited edits. If your current setup makes every change painful—or expensive—you can do better.
>>>REQUEST YOUR WEBSITE REVIEW HERE
Let's dive in.
1. It looks dated—even to you
Open your home page and pretend you have never seen it before. Does it feel crisp and modern? Or does it scream "made in 2013"?
Why the look matters
People form opinions in seconds. A dated layout signals neglect, even if your product is cutting-edge. Fonts that are too small, low-contrast color schemes, cluttered sidebars, or a boxed-in, narrow layout all send visitors hunting for a fresher option.
75 % of consumers admit they judge a company's credibility primarily by its website design

Self-check
- Compare your site to three competitors on desktop and phone.
- Ask a friend who will be blunt: "Does this feel old?"
- Is the copyright mark up to date?
- This is the big one - be honest with yourself. Are you embarrassed to show the website to prospective clients?
What to do
A design refresh may be enough. However, starting from scratch is often faster and cheaper in the long run, especially if your web designer is charging you an hourly rate.
Use a flexible website theme or template so you can refresh colours and fonts later without tearing the site apart.
My take
Design trends shift every two to three years. That does not mean you must chase every fad. A quick style audit each quarter means you will probably only need to make small tweaks rather than a full and expensive redesign every few years.
2. Mobile users must pinch, zoom, or squint
Over 60% of website visits come from phones. Google also ranks pages in a "mobile-first" index. If your website isn't easy to view and navigate on a mobile device, you lose rankings, visitors and, ultimately, money.

Symptoms
- Menu text runs off the edge.
- Buttons are too close together for a thumb tap.
- Images overflow the screen.
- Pop-ups block all content.
Testing tips
- Use your own phone, then borrow another brand—an iPhone and an Android.
- Run Google's free Mobile-Friendly Test and note the warnings.
- Check analytics: if the bounce rate on mobile is far higher than on desktop, device frustration is likely.
Fix options
Unfortunately, if your website is not mobile-friendly, then a full rebuild is your only option.
My take
A phone test takes a few seconds and can be done anywhere. Put it on your calendar every time you publish a new page. If a tiny tweak knocks the layout out of line, you will catch it before users do.
3. It is not generating leads
A website that doesn't generate leads is nothing more than a vanity project.
Website traffic that never converts into customers is like a shop where people browse but never buy. The issue may be design, copy, missing trust signals or a lack of appropriate calls to action. Regardless, the outcome is the same—silence.
Common culprits
- Calls-to-action are non-existent or blend into the background.
- Forms ask for twenty fields when five will do.
- Not having CTAs for people who aren't quite ready to purchase yet, such as a free guide, makes the only next step a high-commitment sale.
- Slow pages that make users exit before the form appears.
Measure first
Set up one simple goal in Google Analytics: a form completion or button click. Watch how many visitors reach that step. If the numbers are low, map the drop-off page and study why.
Boost conversions
- Place one clear call-to-action per screen.
- Offer both "Talk to sales" and a lower-stress option like "Request a free website and SEO audit"
- Add real testimonials near the form.
- Use live chat or an AI chatbot for quick questions that block the sale.
- Have FAQs (frequently asked questions) on your website to overcome potential objections.
Boost your website traffic.
Even a small amount of money spent on targeted PPC ads can generate leads quickly. Search Engine Optimisation provides long-term results. Combining SEO and PPC campaigns is always a winning strategy and can maximise the return on your investment in your website.

4. Making edits is painful—and costly
Small edits should take minutes, not days. Yet many business owners still rely on a developer for every comma change. Worse, each change may carry a fee.
Red flags
- You can't make simple changes yourself.
- Every change incurs a cost.
- It takes time for your website designer to respond or make changes.
Why it happens
Many web design agencies often rely on customers to make changes as a way of increasing their revenue, and they will charge per hour (or part thereof). Independent website designers will also charge for their time but will often be under pressure to get their current project finished and won't prioritise your changes.
Better way
Modern content management systems separate content from structure. You edit the text in a clean dashboard, click save, and the live page updates.
With our managed service, all edits and amendments are included. Clients never ask, "Is this small change worth the cost?" They just improve the page.
My take
Cost fear kills momentum. The next time you avoid fixing a typo or updating an image because it means emailing your developer, mark that as a sign your platform is failing you.
5. Your brand has grown, but the site has not
Businesses evolve. You may have:
- Added new products or services.
- Focused on a specific service
- Narrowed your niche.
- Shifted tone from formal to friendly.
- Rebranded with a fresh colour palette.
When the site still reflects the old you, it creates a trust gap. Users sense the mismatch even if they cannot name it.
Simple check
Read your About page aloud. Does it sound like how you introduce yourself at a networking event today? If not, the site is stuck in the past.
Update path
- Rewrite key pages to match how you describe your business to prospective customers.
- Refresh your photos and replace any stock imagery.
- Adjust the navigation to highlight new services.
Sometimes copy and images are enough. But if the structure blocks new product pages, a rebuild of your website will often be quicker and cheaper.
My take
Brands do mini-pivots often—sometimes every quarter. Plan a light content review each time you tweak your offer so your site reflects the latest move.
Building a habit of review
Catching these five issues early is easier than fixing them after revenue falls. Here is a simple routine I share with clients:
Quarterly health check
Open Google Analytics or Duda's dashboard. Review engagement levels, traffic levels, bounce rate, and top exit pages.
Visual walk-through
Click every main page on a desktop and phone. Note anything that feels slow, broken, or out-of-sync with your brand.
Lead-path test
Fill out your own form. Did the thank-you email arrive? Did you land on a helpful next-step page?
Traffic strategy review
Look at the mix of sources: organic search, paid ads, social, and referrals. Is one channel lagging? Decide whether an SEO sprint, fresh content, or a PPC test could lift numbers.
Cost-of-change audit
Ask: "If we spot an issue today, can we fix it by tomorrow without surprise fees?" If the answer is no, consider a managed plan that removes change friction.
Put these five steps in your calendar now. They take under an hour and can save you a lot of time (and money) in the long term.
What a rebuild can deliver
- Faster load times →, better search rank, and happier users.
- Responsive design → one site that shines on every screen.
- Clear conversion paths → more leads with the same traffic.
- Low-friction editing → marketing moves at the speed of ideas.
- Future-proof branding → the site grows as your story grows.
Pair that rebuild with a smart traffic plan—ongoing SEO to climb organic results and tactical PPC ads for quick wins—and you create a virtuous cycle. More visitors arrive, the site converts them, analytics confirm what works, and you refine again.

Request a free website and SEO review
Final thoughts
A website is not a "set it and forget it" asset. Technology, design trends, and user habits shift fast. The five indicators above are simple mileposts that flag when your site lags behind.
My strongest advice? Treat your site as a living product. Review it often, measure with solid analytics, and invest in traffic strategies that feed it new visitors. When edits are easy and data is clear, you gain the freedom to improve week by week instead of waiting for a crisis.
If you read this list and nodded more than once, a redesign or rebuild is likely due.
The good news is that modern tools make the leap quicker than you think, and a managed service can keep it that way—edits included, surprises excluded.
Ready to find out what a fresh site could do for your bottom line? Take those quarterly review steps today. Your next customer is only a click away—and they will judge what they see in seconds.
About Overt Digital Media
Based on the sunny south-coast triangle of Christchurch, Bournemouth and the New Forest, Overt Digital Media is a lean, friendly studio that turns local ambition into standout web design. We specialise in fast, mobile-first websites that rank well on Google, convert visitors into leads, and are painless to keep updated—because every business, from Highcliffe cafés to New Milton trades, deserves a site that works as hard as they do.
What sets us apart
- Local insight, national reach – we know the quirks of Dorset and Hampshire audiences, yet our builds perform just as well for customers finding you from further afield.
- All-inclusive managed service – unlimited edits and proactive upkeep mean no surprise invoices. You focus on your trade; we keep the pixels perfect.
- Traffic-ready from day one – every site launches with on-page SEO foundations, lightning-fast hosting, and clear pathways for future PPC or content campaigns.
- Straight-talking support – no jargon, no ticket queues. You get direct access to the designer-developer who built your site.
Whether you’re a Bournemouth retailer looking to refresh an ageing Shopify theme, a Christchurch start-up that needs its first website, or a New Forest restaurant brand chasing more summer bookings, Overt Digital Media can help.
Schedule a free, no-pressure website review today—and find out how a sharper, faster, and easier-to-manage site can move your business forward.
Contact Us
