4 Reasons Why Your Website isn't Converting Leads into Sales

Jon Richardson • July 11, 2021

Generate more leads from your website by increasing your conversion rate! 

Get more leads from your website
So, you have spent lots of time and money on designing your new website and it looks great. You have optimised it for the keywords you want to rank for, and it is now ranking higher on Google and attracting many more visitors. So why are you still not getting any more leads?

The answer is that your website just isn’t converting those visitors into sales or leads. But why not? There are many possible answers to that question and this blog looks at a few of those.

The first question you must answer is ‘What actions do you want your customers to take on your website’? Do you want them to buy a product, book an appointment, contact you or download some information? If you do not know the answer to that question, your customers definitely wont and your website will appear confused.

There may be several answers to this question depending on where your customer is in the buying process. That is fine as long as your website is structured in a way that gives a clear path to visitors based upon what stage they are at.


Below are 4 reasons why your website may not be converting.

You don't have enough, or any, Calls to Action (CTAs)

Call to Action are the instructions on your website to your customers telling them what you want them to do next.  CTAs are important because they prompt your visitors to the next step in your sales and marketing process and will push those visitors along to the next stage. 


We consume information on a website differently than we do in a face to face setting. It is predominantly a one way process where we are passively consuming information. When we are talking to someone in person, particularly in a sales setting, we can ask, ‘do you want to buy this’ or ‘let’s book an appointment’.


These questions are called closing in a sales environment and CTAs are your websites’ way of closing the people they are engaging with.


Do not assume that your customers will know what action you will want them to take. Be clear and specific, i.e. ‘Buy Now’, ‘Email us Today’, ‘Call Now’. If your client has to think about what to do next, they probably won’t and will migrate away from your website. Not only does the Call to action on your website need to be clear on what it is you want them to do but it also has to be easy to do it. So make sure your ‘call now’ is linked with a ‘click to call’ function or the ‘buy now’ CTA is linked to that product in your online shop.


Make sure you have many different CTAs on your website strategically placed throughout your website. However, don’t put too many on there as it will be confusing, or worse seen as spamming.

There are too many choices

We all know how overwhelming it can be if we have too many choices. Imagine walking into an artisan coffee shop for the first time and getting asked you whether you wanted a cappuccino, latte, flat white, mocha, then asked you whether you wanted the Colombian, Moroccan, Italian or French blend, then asked whether you wanted full fat, semi skinned, skinny, oat, soya or almond milk! 


When we are presented with too many options it all becomes too much and we all find it difficult to make a decision, even though you may always have a skinny latte. Too many choices results in paralysis and inertia!


It may seem like a great idea to give your website visitors lots of options but all you end up doing is confusing them and making the choice on whether to engage with your website much more dificult.


The problem is exacerbated with websites where there is no one to identify whether your customer is getting overwhelmed, explain or simplify the choices.


Make sure for each call to action on your website there is just have a single clear choice that your customers can take. 

You're not selling on value

Let’s be clear, it doesn't matter how great your website is or what a great job your website designer did building your new website.  Your prospective customers will only proceed or purchase from you it they are getting value. It is your website's job to tell them what value they will be getting, ‘what’s in it for them’! 


That may not always be some financial value such as a discount it could be free advice or tips on how to improve their website traffic or conversion!


Regardless of whether you are trying to sell a chair or convince someone to book a free marketing audit you must sell the value.  Selling value has been the subject of many books and training courses so it is obviously too big a subject to cover in detail in this blog. But at a basic level you need to avoid what are known as ‘so what statements'.


Let’s take the free marketing audit example above. I could tell you that “Overt Digital Media provide a free 50 point marketing audit” to which you could say “so what”. I could then say “it looks at 50 ways you can promote your company or service”. Again “so what” but if I told you that “our free marketing audit will identify 50 ways you can engage with your customers more effectively, win new customers more easily and grow your business quicker and easier”. All of a sudden you can see the value in spending 30 minutes out of your day to take the audit.  By the way if that's something you'd like to do, please contact me to arrange your free marketing audit.


Similarly, if we take the chair example above. I could say “it’s a chair” but you could say “so what” to which I would say “you can sit on it, it is really comfortable” again, “so what” but if I say “I have this chair, it is really comfortable and allows you to rest and recover so that you feel relaxed and will have more energy to do things you want to do for the rest of the day!” All of sudden you can see the value of buying that chair.

Your website isn't mobile friendly.

It is a fact that the majority of website searches are conducted on mobile (54.8% in the first quarter of 2021). If your website isn’t mobile friendly you will find that visitors to your website will move on very quickly and your bounce rate will be high.


Simply put if your website isn’t mobile friendly you need to speak to a web designer and get a new website on a modern platform that is easy to navigate on mobile devices.


The latest generation of websites incorporate Artificial Intelligence that can adapt the design of your website for each user based on their device, the time, number of visits and location. This improves the experience of users making your website much more engaging.


For example if someone was visiting your website on their mobile during your opening hours you could change a Call to Action from ‘Email Us’ to ‘Call Now’. Or if they were near your location rather than ‘Call Us’ it could be ‘Visit Us’ and a map could appear with your location!


Artificial Intelligence has been shown to increase the conversion rate of websites by up to 19% and can become a game changer helping you to significantly grow your business. 


We have been incorporating A.I. into our customers websites for a long time now and we have see massive improvements in their conversion rates.  Often this has resulted in significant growth for our customers.   You can find out more about A.I. websites on our website.

Conclusion

There are many moving parts to a great website.  Not only does it have to have fantastic design and be pleasing to the eye it must also guide your prospective customers along a journey.  To do that you must incorporate several elements which can be summarised as, great design, compelling content, and a clear path to follow.  Fail on any of these and you will be losing business.


Building a website is cheap and easy, building a good website is hard and building a great website is a work of art and it is worth employing a professional web designer to ensure that your website works for you and not the other way round.

About Overt Digital Media

Overt Digital Media are a digital marketing agency based in Christchurch on the edge of The New Forest.  We specialise in website design, mobile Apps and affordable search engine optimisation.


Our websites, mobile apps and SEO services are designed to be affordable for small businesses and to deliver tangible results.  We use the latest technology and platforms and combine that with proactive advice and consultancy for our customers to help them acquire more customers and to grow their business.

By Jon Richardson December 7, 2025
Struggling for leads? 10 quick SEO secrets, UK agencies don't want you to know. Your competitors are getting all the leads while you're struggling to get noticed online. Sound familiar? Here's the truth most digital marketing agencies in Christchurch don't want you to discover: local SEO isn't rocket science, and you don't need a computer science degree to make it work. Most agencies overcomplicate things on purpose – it keeps you dependent on their services. But the reality is that small tweaks to how you present your business online can dramatically increase the number of local customers finding and choosing you over your competition. Let's break down the exact strategies that work, explained in plain English. Secret #1: Stop Fighting for "Plumber" – Win "Emergency Plumber Christchurch" Instead Forget trying to rank for broad terms like "plumber" or "electrician." You're competing against every business in the UK for those keywords. Instead, focus on what people actually type when they need your services urgently. Think like your customers. When someone's toilet is overflowing at 2am, they're not searching for "plumber." They're typing "emergency plumber near me" or "24 hour plumber in Christchurch, Dorset." What to do right now: Make a list of your services, then add your suburb or area to each one. Use these phrases naturally throughout your website content, especially on your main pages. Secret #2: Create Landing Pages for Each Area You Serve This is where most small businesses miss out on massive opportunities. Instead of one generic "Services" page, create separate pages for each suburb or area you work in. For example, if you're a carpet cleaner, don't just have one page about carpet cleaning. Create: "Carpet Cleaning in Highcliffe" "Carpet Cleaning in Christchurch" "Carpet Cleaning in Burton" What to do right now: Pick your top 3 service areas and create dedicated pages for each. Include local landmarks, mention the specific challenges customers in that area face, and use photos from actual jobs in those neighbourhoods. Secret #3: Your Google Business Profile is Your Secret Weapon Your Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business) is often the first thing potential customers see. Yet most businesses treat it like an afterthought. Here's what separates the businesses getting calls from those being ignored: Post updates at least once a week Respond to every review within 24 hours Upload new photos monthly Keep your opening hours religiously up to date Use the "Products" section to showcase your key services What to do right now: Log into your Google Business Profile today. Check every detail is correct, upload 5 new photos, and write a post about a recent job or customer success story. 
By Jon Richardson November 22, 2025
Why Local Businesses Are Moving Away from Directories - And Finding Bigger Wins with Google Business Profile
By Jon Richardson November 17, 2025
Networking for Trades - Good & Bad
By Jon Richardson November 10, 2025
AI for the Local Business Owner: What’s Worth Using and What’s Just Hype!?! AI is everywhere right now. Every week, there’s a new tool, new feature or new “game-changer” that promises to transform your business overnight. For many local business owners, it feels like déjà vu — we’ve heard all this before. And yet… this time it’s different. AI isn’t just a buzzword for big tech firms anymore. It’s filtering down into everyday tools small businesses already use — your website builder, Google Business Profile, CRM, social media scheduler and even your email inbox. The challenge now isn’t whether to use AI, but which tools are actually worth your time — and which ones are just shiny distractions that slow you down. So, let’s cut through the noise and look at where AI really earns its keep for small, local businesses. The AI Tools That Actually Save You Time AI Email and Admin Assistants If you spend half your life replying to repetitive customer emails — booking confirmations, pricing queries, FAQs — AI can handle a lot of that grunt work for you. Tools like ChatGPT, Claude, or Microsoft Copilot can draft replies, check tone, or even integrate with Gmail or Outlook to automatically suggest responses. But the key is to train them with your own tone of voice . You don’t want robotic replies that sound like a call centre in space. Spend an hour teaching the system how you talk to customers, short, polite, straight to the point — and it’ll start saving you hours a week. If your inbox is a mess, Superhuman or Shortwave uses AI to summarise long threads and prioritise messages that actually need your attention. That’s a lifesaver when you’re on the go. AI Scheduling and Note-Taking If you use Zoom, Teams or Google Meet, you’ve probably noticed new “AI companion” features. They can record, summarise and create action lists from your meetings all automatically. Fireflies.ai and Fathom do this well and integrate with most platforms. Imagine finishing a customer call and having a neat summary of what was discussed, follow-ups and deadlines emailed to you within minutes. That’s practical AI. It doesn’t wow anyone on LinkedIn, but it gives you time back — and that’s what matters. AI Social Media Tools AI can now write your captions, crop your videos and even schedule posts at the times your audience is most active. Vista Social (which we use at OVERT DIGITAL MEDIA ) does a solid job of this, as does Later and Metricool. What’s worth using: AI tools that write drafts you can edit quickly not ones that try to take over the whole creative process. The point isn’t to hand everything over to the bot; it’s to speed up the parts you hate doing. The AI Tools That Actually Generate Leads AI isn’t just about saving time; it can actively help you win new business — if you use it the right way. Google Ads and Meta Ads Optimisation You’ve probably noticed that Google and Meta now talk about “Smart Campaigns” and “Advantage+” ads. That’s AI at work — algorithms that automatically test different ad headlines, images and targeting combinations to find what performs best. It’s far from perfect, but it’s powerful when used properly. The mistake small businesses make is letting the system run on autopilot without checking what it’s doing. AI works best when you feed it good data and clear goals. You still need to know what to target, where your audience lives, and what problem you’re solving. Let AI do the testing and optimisation — but don’t hand it the steering wheel. If you’re managing ads yourself, use AdCreative.ai to generate high-converting ad visuals and copy in minutes. It’s simple, quick and doesn’t look like it came from a robot. AI for Local SEO and Google Business Profile This is one area where AI genuinely gives small businesses a fighting chance against national brands. AI-powered tools like Local Falcon, BrightLocal and Surfer Local can scan your entire Google Maps ranking area and show exactly where you’re visible (and where you’re not). That’s data you could never get manually. You can then use AI to help write keyword-optimised posts, service descriptions, and responses to reviews. If you do it properly, you can dominate your local area because most of your competitors won’t even know these tools exist. We’ve tested this ourselves, and the difference can be night and day. Clients go from being invisible outside their postcode to ranking across an entire 10-mile radius in a matter of months. To learn more, check out our LOCAL SEO service page. AI Chat and Lead-Capture Agents Here’s a huge one. AI chat agents can now do far more than pop up on your site with “How can I help you today?”. They can qualify leads, answer FAQs, book appointments, and even follow up automatically. Tools like Tidio, Drift, or GoHighLevel AI Agents make it easy to build one that fits your tone and brand. Used properly, they can turn missed calls into booked jobs, especially for trades and service businesses where speed of response is everything. But be warned: this only works when your bot feels human. If it gives robotic, generic answers, it will kill trust instantly. Spend time training it with real questions and examples from your past conversations. You can see how we use automation like this on our AI Websites page. The Tools That Sound Exciting but Rarely Pay Off AI image generators, video avatars and content mills have their place, but most small businesses waste time chasing gimmicks that never generate a penny in return. AI Image Generators Everyone loves playing with Midjourney and DALL-E — but unless you’re in creative design or product marketing, it’s mostly just fun. They’re great for social graphics, concept visuals and mock-ups, but they take time to master. You’ll still need editing, branding and human judgment to make the results usable. Verdict: Nice to play with, not a daily essential. AI Blogging Tools You’ve probably seen the “write me 10 SEO-optimised blogs instantly” type tools. They can churn out text, sure, but it’s usually bland, repetitive and reads like it was written by a committee of robots. If your aim is to rank or build trust locally, that won’t cut it. AI is brilliant for drafting outlines and ideas (we use it for that all the time), but you still need a human to add expertise, local context and personality. Google’s algorithm is smart enough now to spot thin, generic AI content. You’ll do better with one well-written blog a month that genuinely helps people than with ten AI-generated ones that don’t say anything new. AI Video Avatars These have exploded in popularity, but most look awkward and fake when used for local service businesses. Unless you’re creating explainer videos or training content, it’s better to film yourself (or your team) for authenticity. AI avatars can’t replace genuine personality and personality is what sells local services. How to Tell if an AI Tool Is Worth It Before you sign up for yet another shiny new AI platform, ask three questions: Does it save me time every week? If it doesn’t make a recurring difference, it’s not worth keeping. Does it improve my marketing results? Does it generate more leads, improve conversions, or give insights I couldn’t get otherwise? Can I see myself actually using it? Most AI tools fail not because they’re bad, but because people forget they exist. Pick a few that fit neatly into your daily workflow. A good test is this: if you stop using it for a week and nothing gets harder, cancel it. The AI Tools We’d Recommend to a Local Business Right Now If you’re short on time and want a focused list, here’s what genuinely helps most small businesses: ChatGPT or Claude – for quick drafts, emails, ideas and posts. GoHighLevel AI Agent – for lead capture and automated follow-ups. Local Falcon – to track and improve your local visibility. Vista Social – to manage social posts and analyse engagement. Fireflies.ai – to summarise calls and meetings. AdCreative.ai – to create better-performing ad creatives quickly. Everything else? Nice to have, but not essential. The Future: AI as Your Silent Business Partner The smartest small businesses in 2025 won’t be the ones that chase every new trend. They’ll be the ones that quietly integrate AI into their day-to-day operations and never look back. AI won’t replace you (yet), but it will replace a lot of your admin, manual marketing, and repetitive customer interactions. That means you can spend more time doing what you actually enjoy, running your business, talking to customers, and delivering great work. Final Thoughts Most AI hype is built around things that look impressive. But the real gold is in the boring stuff — automation, data insights and everyday time-savers that keep your business moving faster than your competitors. Start small. Automate one thing. Measure the impact. Then add the next piece.vvWithin a few months, you’ll wonder how you ever managed without it. If you’d like help identifying the right AI tools for your business, or want us to integrate them into your marketing systems, BOOK A CHAT WITH THE TEAM AT OVERT DIGITAL MEDIA . We’ll show you what’s genuinely worth your investment… and what belongs firmly in the bin.
By Jon Richardson November 2, 2025
How AI Video Can Help You Win More Customers and Grow Your Business Faster
By Jon Richardson October 26, 2025
Forget doing everything, focus on marketing activities that actually drive leads and growth.
By Jon Richardson October 5, 2025
Take Control of Your Marketing with Our 73-Point Self-Service Audit.
By Jon Richardson September 28, 2025
Follow our 7-step process to get more Google Reviews for your business.
By Jon Richardson September 20, 2025
The 12-Point Checklist to See if Your Website is Up to Scratch
By Jon Richardson September 7, 2025
Why regular marketing is essential (and easy)!